Brotherhood Mutual® welcomes
the Michigan Region of the Missionary Church

Partners in Ministry

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company is proud to be the preferred property and liability insurer of the Michigan Region of the Missionary Church. Our mission of Advancing the Kingdom by Serving the Church® is our pledge to help your ministry thrive. Together, we improve risk management, create safer places to worship, provide care for clergy, and offer access to valuable resources. We design our coverages and services around the unique needs of Christian organizations, so you can focus on ministry.

Request a Quote

"At Evident, we’ve had our insurance with Brotherhood Mutual through the Pierce Carter Agency since 2008. There are inevitable challenges in ministry, but they have been beside us as a great help every step of the way."

Josh Hossler, Lead Pastor | Evident Church - Chesterfield, MI

"We have used Brotherhood Mutual from the Pierce-Carter Agency for several years. The insurance agent goes above and beyond to make sure our church is well informed and has the correct insurance coverage tailored to our programs and needs."

Pastor Tim McCulloch, Director of Finances | Colonial Woods Missionary Church - Port Huron, MI


Meet Your Local Agent

Jared Short

517-676-9366

jared@piercecarter.com


Pierce-Carter Agency

PierceCarter.com


Our Products

Property Coverage

Buildings and Personal Property, Equipment, Building Projects.

Learn More

Liability Insurance

Religious Acts and Communications, Nursery/Childcare Supervision, Directors and Officers.

Learn More

Ministry Stewardship Resources

Tools to help defend your ministry against common property and liability claims.

Learn More

Legal AssistSM

Our legal team provides resources that can help you navigate today’s complex legal landscape, at no cost to you.*

Learn More

Safety Library

Browse hundreds of articles, checklists, and sample forms.

Visit the Library

MinistryWorks® Payroll Services

Management of Tax Withholdings and Deductions, Full Service Direct Deposit, Tax Return Filing.

Learn More

Mission Travel Insurance

Security & Emergency Medical Evacuation, Accident & Illness Medical Expense, Ministry Discounted Airfare.

Learn More

Workers’ Compensation

Employee Injuries, Employer’s Liability, and Wage Replacement.

Protect your Staff

Vehicle Protection

Liability, Personal Injury, Physical Damage.

Learn More

*Important information: Brotherhood Mutual is pleased to provide Legal Assist as a complimentary resource. The services we offer through Legal Assist are intended to provide general legal information to our current and prospective policyholders. The information we provide is intended to be helpful, but it does not constitute legal advice and is not a substitute for the advice from a licensed attorney in your area. Accordingly, no attorney/client relationship is created through this process, and no legal advice will be provided. We strongly encourage you to regularly consult with a local attorney as part of your risk management program.


Find the gaps lurking in your ministry‘s insurance policy.

The day after a claim is filed could be a major headache if your ministry’s insurance policy lacks coverage where you need it most. Critical coverage gaps can put your ministry at risk, especially when it comes to:

  • Security Operations Liability
  • Counseling Liability
  • Religious Freedom
  • Sexual Acts Liability
  • Worldwide Liability
  • Traumatic Incident Response
  • Directors & Officers Liability
  • Legal Liability Defense Cost Reimbursement

Think you may have gaps in coverage? Contact your local agent to review your ministry's insurance policy today.